In the article “Supplied products and services must meet your end requirements,” in the April 2026 issue of Canadian Metalworking, we looked at the internal quality of an organization and how ISO methodology applies to final product quality. ISO provides great guidance for everything, identifying many shalls identified within all standards. What it doesn’t do is provide guidance on how to make the requirements happen in a meaningful and value-added way.
Some companies don’t truly understand all the inputs that contribute to a robust calculation of the cost of poor quality (COPQ). That lack of insight can be much like high blood pressure—a silent killer. The numbers can add up quickly, and to make matters worse, many manufacturers don't properly track or assign these costs within their financial reporting.
Although opinions differ about which contributors should be included in the calculation, a comprehensive assessment should consider the following nine factors, although the list may not be exhaustive for every manufacturer.
1. Simple Rework Labour
Many companies think COPQ is limited to the extra labour required to address a discrepant product through rework. Often, the calculation is simple: rework hours × hourly rate = cost of rework. However, this calculation accounts only for the labour required to correct a single problem. To determine the total rework labour cost, you must multiply this amount by the number of problems or parts requiring rework.
This is often where companies stop calculating COPQ, but while it’s an important cost, it only scratches the surface. There are many other costs to consider.
2. Replacement Parts or Materials
Sometimes a manufacturer must buy more supplier material to replace the discrepant material. Usually, the company bears this cost initially and sometimes must fight with the supplier to be compensated. Most manufacturers will bear the cost automatically, as they need to keep their production lines moving to meet customer demand. Often, after the problem is solved and rectified, the company loses track of having incurred the cost of new material and never gets compensated for the material it couldn’t use.
3. Logistics
When you need to replace parts, you may also need to pay for shipping and handling to receive the new parts. If you have the right relationship with your supplier, sometimes they will pick up these costs. However, the supplier may sometimes require the discrepant parts to be returned for further evaluation and root cause analysis.
These activities can add significant logistics costs—not just freight charges but sometimes also brokerage and duties for cross-border shipments. The shipping method also matters. Expedited or overnight shipments required to resolve an urgent quality issue can be substantially more expensive than regular ground transportation. Internal labour must also be considered, including the time required to prepare and return discrepant parts and receive, inspect, and handle replacement parts.
Pour lire la suite : https://www.canadianmetalworking.com/canadianmetalworking/blog/healthsafety/the-hidden-cost-of-poor-quality-in-manufacturing
.png)
